A Study of Various Biases Affecting Financial Decisions

Exploring Biases in Financial Decision-Making

by Swati Anand*, Prof. Kushendra Mishra,

- Published in Journal of Advances and Scholarly Researches in Allied Education, E-ISSN: 2230-7540

Volume 16, Issue No. 2, Feb 2019, Pages 921 - 926 (6)

Published by: Ignited Minds Journals


ABSTRACT

Financial economics, the elements of stock markets, and the activities of specialists in that as a leader, are themes which are at last explored with different forthcoming by bunch scientists. A significant discussion has been progressing for most recent three decades between two schools of considerations 'rationalists' who expect that economic operators carry on sanely, against 'behaviorists', who accept that they act in efficiently silly ways. In the financial market, the speculators' desires, which assume a pivotal job impacts their Behavior. Actually, this influences the volume of exchanging, the cost of the protections and additionally the other financial tasks. Financial specialists display unreasonable behavior in their basic leadership. The basic leadership process itself is viewed as a psychological procedure as the speculators need to settle on a choice dependent on different choices accessible to them. Different financial models like CAPM (Capital Asset Pricing Model) and Black Scholes alternative valuation models accept that speculators are making unbiased figures, carries on totally normal and the financial market is competitive. In this Research Study, we reviewed the existing literature on various biases affecting financial decisions in detail.

KEYWORD

financial economics, biases, financial decisions, stock markets, behaviorists

I. INTRODUCTION

Traditional finance expresses that Humans demonstration sane. They attempt to boost utility by choosing the best choice among the accessible options in the midst of vulnerability. Proficient market speculation expresses that markets are productive and costs mirror all the accessible information. In any case, this is in logical inconsistency with the truth. Humans will in general act irrational while making investment decisions. Behavioral finance attempts to discover the reasons for such irrational behavior among people. Behavioral finance centers on the psychological parts of why such irrational behavior emerges among people. It is accepted that psychological biases has an effect on investment decision making which prompts less returns. It is additionally discovered that absence of information and memory mistakes affects irrational decision making. Financial specialist behavior regularly goes astray from logic and reason, and speculators show numerous behavior biases that impact their investment decision-making forms. Behavioral finance is a developing field of study which is generally new and having its provenance from decision theory. Behavioral finance is a multidisciplinary look into area that joins psychology and finance and examines the issues that affect the decision-making process and clarifies the irrational idea of people, groups and organizations. Behavioral finance attempts to address those psychological snares that are defied while making decisions under vulnerability. Investments are made to acquire returns and capital thankfulness to beat vulnerability in future. Decision making for investing includes biases which affects the presentation of investments. The corporate exhibition of a firm is primarily subject to financial arranging. Financial supervisors who are associated with decisions either long haul or present moment are expected to advance the degree of financing which is reasonable for the corporate exhibition. The long haul financial decision incorporates the corporate procedures for capital structure and the dividend policy decisions. Capital structure decision is the structure of debt and equity. Debt section is identified with outer subsidizing which is gotten by firms while equity is comprised of two sections that are raised capital of the firm and selling of equity to outside of firm, at some point chiefs increment the debt level of financing or equity level with the end goal of better corporate execution.

II. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT

As per Remund (2010) "Financial literacy is a measure of how much one understands key

planning, while aware of life occasions and changing economic conditions." According to Adams and Rau (2011), "Maybe one of the most powerful findings over the writing is that financial literacy (a psychological factor…) assumes a key job in financial preparation for retirement. Both test and non-trial studies show that understanding the basic standards of saving, for example, accumulating funds, has an immediate impact on financial preparation. This impact holds subsequent to controlling for statistic qualities." Analysis of these definitions demonstrates that financial literacy will keep on being a significant research area. Be that as it may, just investigation won't help. To discover great arrangements, the attention ought to be on execution and assessment of various procedures to improve the financial literacy levels of population. As low financial literacy is destructive for individual's financial wellbeing and country's economic wellbeing, prudent methodologies are important to improve financial literacy. As indicated by McMahon et al (2011) sound financial management is critical to the survival and prosperity of small undertakings of different types. Investigations of reasons for small business disappointment definitely show poor or thoughtless financial management to be the most significant reason. The writer makes reference to that recognition of such findings in the ongoing years have seen increased consideration towards financial management in small business preparing and instructive projects and books and articles composed for small business. He additionally says that it isn't unreasonable to contemplate whether this consideration has visibly affected the manner by which small businesses are worked. It appears to be fitting to audit, and endeavors have been made to incorporate accessible observational research findings concerning the financial management practices of small business in North America. Such a survey can prompt improved understanding of both the research led till date and the financial management practices under investigation. Furthermore, it can go about as an improvement for future research. Nguyen. KM (2011) in his thesis, provides engaging findings of financial management practices and financial qualities and exhibits the synchronous effect of financial management practices and financial attributes on SME profitability. Also, the research study provides a model of SME profitability, in which profitability was found to be related to financial management practices and financial qualities. Except for debt ratios, every single other variable including current ratio, total asset turnover, working capital management and short-term planning practices, fixed asset management and long-term planning practices, and financial and accounting information financial management practices and contributes to the knowledge. A study by LeCornu et al (2016) has illuminated the financial target of small specialty units. They found that financial management of small venture is or ought to be subjectively as well as quantitatively unique in relation to that of enormous undertakings. It likewise gives the idea that behavior and decision making in small ventures are unequivocally appended to the individual inspirations of the proprietor administrators. McMahon and Davies (2014) in their exact work had remarked that maintaining a business successfully require a mindfulness and great or appropriate knowledge of how the business is getting along by the proprietor administrator of a small business on an everyday basis. Aside from legitimate prerequisites, there is a down to earth need to keep adequate records to guarantee that business exercises can proceed without issue and appropriate way. In any case, the fields of accounting and finance presently can't seem to give an acknowledged regulating theory demonstrating which financial reports are most profitable in financial management and how regularly they ought to be utilized. A study by Holmes and Nicholls (2018) presumed that the sum and nature of accounting information arranged or gained is reliant on number of working and ecological factors like, business measure, age, mechanical grouping, proprietor directors training and so forth. The study likewise demonstrates that there is a major hole between the proprietor supervisor, mindfulness, and the employments of financial management strategies. They (proprietor directors of small specialty units) are wandering into business without appropriate accounting and financial (control) 'know-how'. Ashim Kumar Das and Nikhil Bhusan Dey (2012) articulation that "Small is beautiful" is increasingly pertinent to the Indian situation as small specialty units contribute about 40 percent of gross modern worth and 7 percent of her GDP. Small business is the main beam of trust in a huge number of individuals to get by as the majority of the states are modernly in reverse, having poor infrastructure facilities and subsistence agribusiness. Developing writing on financial management supports the contention that in small business, financial management is one of the key issues. It increases the achievement rate as well as influences the degree of performance of a business. This research paper embraces an exploratory study by raising a few inquiries on the financial management practices of small businesses in India and endeavors to discover exact avocation on the typical practices by small businessmen. The research proves that there is a wide hole between

12

management and support of appropriate business records. While the exploratory idea of the study does not enable its results to be summed it up, be that as it may, recommends the requirement for further theory advancement in the field of financial management for small business and formulation of hypotheses for more extensive experimental investigation in future.

III. FACTORS AFFECTING INVESTORS

Chandra et al (2011) recognized some psychological and relevant factors affecting individual investor behavior in Delhi and NCR and which factors impacts behavior the most. Essential information were gathered from the investors. Head Component Analysis was done to look at the behavior of investors. The results express that judiciousness and precautious attitude, conservatism, under certainty, informational asymmetry, and financial compulsion influences Indian individual investor behavior the most. These factors influences the behavior of investors the most. Mathur (2014) endeavored to research different factors that were in charge of planning better financial measures for the retirement among test population of Indian ladies ostracize's in UAE. Test of the study incorporates 600 ladies members who are workers of instructive institutions, global organizations and neighborhood endeavors of Abu Dhabi, Ajman, Dubai, Fujairah, Ras al-Khaimah, Sharjah, and Umm al-Quwain. The results express that 40% of respondents were found to have basic knowledge about the investments. The association of age was additionally found to be sure with main role of portfolio and sort of investment whereas it doesn't have an association with understanding the investments and ownership of emergency funds. The present study additionally uncovered that there was no association between business and knowledge rate in understanding investments, main role of portfolio, kind of investment, as well as emergency finance. At the point when the association of income was dissected, it was found that there was no association with the factors, knowledge rate in understanding of investments, sort of investment, and emergency finance while there was an association with the main role of portfolio. The patterns saw possessing emergency funds demonstrated that there were no emergency funds in case of no tutoring, essential and optional tutoring classifications while ownership of emergency funds were found among under alumni and post graduate classes of instructive capabilities. A huge perception of the study was found that there is no association between understanding the investments with the main role of portfolio, kind of investment, emergency reserve, and investment in stocks and there was a be significantly associated with the respondents' understanding, feasible arrangements concerning retirement. Warne et al (2012) endeavored to understand the attitude, perception and the issues investors as a rule faces in stock market, with exceptional reference to Ambala region in Haryana, India. Essential information were gathered with the assistance of study technique from investors. The results demonstrates that investors assimilate their goal of saving, factors which impacts saving and different wellsprings of information while making investment decisions. Investors' likewise give due significance to their yearly income and yearly savings as income causes him in choosing the degree of savings. Results additionally demonstrates that investors' are completely mindful about the stock market.

Prosad et al (2012) explored the crowding impact in India. It has been tried utilizing relapse model utilizing CSSD and CSAD system. The result express that crowding behavior does not exists in Indian markets meaning that they are productive. It very well may be deduced from the result that Indian investors know and better informed. Anyway it exists in bull phase when nearness of grouping was tried for extraordinary market developments. Grouping is existing when the market goes up, yet it doesn't exists when the market goes down. It might be because of the way that investor's pursues market swarm when the market is in increasing state rather than following when market is in decreasing state.

IV. DECISION MAKING IN FINANCIAL INVESTMENTS

Jains et al (2012) inspected the psychology and inclinations of an investor living in Udaipur through an organized Questionnaire. The findings displays that investors are very mindful while making their investment decisions and lean toward the pause and watch policy. They put resources into both primary as well as secondary market. Investors are likewise affected by the measure of information existing in market. They are likewise impacted by different behavioral biases and psychological factors as judgment criteria, for example contribution of rationality and irrationality in investment behavior accepts them increasingly careful as it can influence the way of life, asset worth and association with others. Babajide et al (2012) analyzed impact of different behavioral biases while decision making on performance of security market in Nigeria by drafting a poll. Primary information were gathered

behavioral biases and stock market performance. Henceforth, effect of behavioral biases exist however it isn't so extreme in the Nigerian security market. Ahmed et al. (2011) examined the investment decision making behavior of small investors in Lahore Stock Exchange. Reactions of 300 randomly chosen small investors have been gathered through study technique for information accumulation. The findings express that behavioral biases do influence the investment decision making of small investors as they depend more on behavioral finance theories rather than conventional financial theories. Therefore, the results does not support the presence of the standards of rationality while making an investment related decision. Tripathi (2009) examined perceptions, inclinations and different investment systems received by investors in Indian stock market. The results express that investors embraces both basic factors, for example, measure, book to market equity, price earnings ratio, influence and so on as well as specialized methodology while making investment decisions. Utilizing both the methodologies can help in clarifying better cross sectional varieties in equity returns in India. Mohanta et al (2011) examined that investors settles on investment decisions to satisfy their financial, social and psychological need. "They do mull over other benefits like wellbeing and security, getting occasional return or dividends, high capital addition, verified future, liquidity, easy purchase, tax reduction, meeting future possibility and so forth while taking decisions". Ali (2011) analyzed connection between individual investors' apparent financial performance of organizations and their exchanging aims, and the mediating impact of organizations pictures on the connections. It endeavors to locate that individual investors' exchanging decisions are straightforwardly influenced by their apparent hazard, saw returns and trust legitimately while attitude towards brand incompletely mediates the connections. The result express that investors assesses hazard and return associated with organizations and does not get impacted distinctly by passionate factors which making their decisions.

V. BIASES AFFECTING IN FINANCIAL DECISION MAKING

Weinstein (2010), who detailed that a larger piece of students confided in their chances of occasions. Loss Aversion was the first presented in behavioral finance. Loss Aversion is alluding to individual‘s powerful urge to firmly organize of maintains a strategic distance from losses to get an arrival. Loss Aversion is commonly forewarned to be in charge of the best piece of hazard avoidance. The connection between behavioral biases and long term financial fundamental goals of the examinations so far directed on the behavioral biases were to make mindfulness among those persons who are biased specifically conditions and may settle on irrational decisions. As every one of the assumptions of rationality can't be accomplished. Thaler, (2016) mental accounting is a lot of psychological operations utilized by individual and family unit to sort out assess and monitor financial exercises. It manages recording and outlining business dealings and financial exchanges in books and further investigations it, confirms it and reports the results. Mental accounting is progressively related to the human psychological investigation of long term financial decisions, as a man dependably needs to be on safe side of his investments in the interim hazard taking is likewise an unavoidable human wonder. For each human being, past experience is the principle wellspring of information while making a decision. In totality, a man forms the information that he encountered from his past which further influences his current decisions. Optimism bias is normally portrayed as the stirred up conviction that one's chances of experiencing a negative occasion are lower (or a positive occasion higher) than that of one's sidekicks. For capital structure decisions, Meinert (2011) contended that entrepreneurial managers are exceedingly impacted by optimism bias. The reason for the dangerous debt management in today's corporate firms is because of the very optimistic methodology of top managers. For capital planning decisions, two kinds of optimistic managers are found in literature; one believes that organizations' hazardous protections are underestimated by capital market and they remotely decrease positive net present values (NPV) and the second optimistic chief believes in over values of their own corporate projects and wish to put resources into negative net present values. People who are increasingly optimistic, work more earnestly, want to leave progressively seasoned (along these lines would like to live increasingly more substance with his/her occupation), have greater capacity to do it again and they place more in individual stocks and extra more. Optimism bias, in decision making, is among the heartiest revelations in exploration on social perceptions and appreciations, over the span of the latest two decades. Diverse information prescribes that people tend to be unreasonably optimistic about what's to come. Ali and Anis (2012) contended that the top level decisions, when all is said in done, are driven by enthusiastic biases. The top managers will in general be optimistic when planning for the investment of new projects and they are probably

12

optimistic are progressively inclined to the better future performance of the firm than others. Notwithstanding, the decision of optimistic managers contrasts from others as they gain a less enhanced portfolio because they are increasingly inclined to the better future performance. The results existing in the literature have been contradictory up until now. Malmendier and Tate (2005) contended that optimistic managers will be increasingly certain on self-capacities and will depend on the interior financing sources rather than drawing closer towards outer sources. Their study reasoned that optimistic managers approach the residual dividend policy while financing the capital for new projects and the dividend payments will be precluded as the managers will organize usage of the earnings for new financing. On the off chance that the managers pursue residual dividend policy, they should avoid the dividend dispersions for a specific timeframe, in this way decreasing the estimation of the firm, eventually increasing the hazard for the firm.

VI. CONCLUSION

From the point by point literature review, it is understood that many specialists have said that the business condition is distinctive as indicated by the style of management as well as the way of life that the family inherited from generation to generation. The research proves that there is a wide hole between the theory of financial management and genuine practice to demonstrate that organizations not doing great are more averse to know about financial management and support of appropriate business records. The impact of behavioral biases on corporate performance through long term financial decisions and likewise check how these long term financial decisions influence the corporate performance. The study underlines the significance of instilling behavioral biases in long term financial decisions for corporate performance. This study has attempted to draw a reasonable picture of biases impact on corporate performance through dividend policy and capital structure decisions.

REFERENCES

1. Weinstein, N. D. (2010). Unrealistic optimism about future life events. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39(5), p. 806. 2. Thaler, R. H. (2016). Mental accounting matters. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 12(3), pp. 183–206. 3. Meinert, J. R. (2011). Financial Advice from a Business Veteran. Journal of Accountancy, 171(6), p. 134.

7(1).

5. Ben-David, I., Graham, J. R., & Harvey, C. R. (2017). Managerial Overconfidence and Corporate Policies. NBER working paper (Vol. December). https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1079308 6. Malmendier, U., & Tate, G. (2005). CEO overconfidence and corporate investment. The Journal of Finance, 60(6), pp. 2661–2700 7. Chandra, A. & Kumar, R. (2011). Determinants of Individual Investor Behaviour: An Orthogonal Linear Transformation Approach. Retrieved from http://mpra.ub.unimuenchen.de/29722 8. Mathur, M. (2014). Investment decision making for retirement planning in the shadow of holistic decision making model: A study of Indian expatriate women in UAE (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Banasthali Vidyapith, Rajasthan. 9. Suman, & Warne, D. (2012). Investment Behaviour of Individual Investor in Stock Market. IJRFM, 2(2), pp. 432-439. 10. Prosad, J., Kapoor, S., & Sengupta, J. (2012). An Examination of Herd Behaviour: An Empirical Study on Indian Equity Market. International Conference on Economics and Finance Research, pp. 11-15. 11. Jains, D., & Dashora, N. (2012). A study on impact of market movements on investment decision-An empirical analysis with respect to investors in Udaipur, Rajasthan. Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce, 2(2), pp. 78-88. 12. Babajide, A., & Adetiloye, K. (2012). Investors‘ Behavioural Biases and the Security Market: An Empirical Study of the Nigerian Security Market. Accounting and Finance Research,, 1(1), pp. 219-229. 13. Ahmed, N., Ahmad, Z., & Khan, S. (2011). Behavioural Finance: Shaping the Decisions of Small Investors of Lahore Stock Exchange. Interdisciplinary Journal of Research in Business, 1(2), pp. 38-43. 14. Sehgal, S., & Tripathi, N. (2009). Investment Strategies ... Equity Market.

15. Mohanta, G., & Debasish, S. (2011). A Study on Investment Preferences among Urban Investors in Orissa. Prerana: Journal of Management Thought and Practice, 3(1), pp. 1-9. 16. Ali, A. (2011). Predicting Individual Investors‘ Intention to Invest: An Experimental Analysis of Attitude as a Mediator. International Journal of Human and Social Sciences, 6(1). 17. Remund, D.L. (2010). Financial literacy explicated: The case for a clearer definition in an increasingly complex economy. Journal of Consumers Affairs, Vol. 44, pp. 276-295. 18. Adams, G. A., & Rau, B. L. (2011). Putting off tomorrow to do what you want today: Planning for retirement. Amer. Psychologist, 66(3), pp. 180–192. 19. McMahon, Richard G. P. and Holmes, Scott (2011), Small Business Financial Management Practices in North America: A Literature Review, Academic journal article from Journal of Small Business Management, Vol. 29, No. 2 20. Nguyen. K.M. (2011). 'Financial management and profitability of small and medium enterprises', DBA thesis, Southern Cross University, Lismore, NSW. 21. Le Cornu, Mark. R.; Mc Mahon, Richard G.P.; Forsaith, David M. and Stanger, Anthory, M.J. (2016), ―The Small Enterprise Financial objective Function‖. Journal of Small Business Management. USA. July. 22. McMahon, R.P.G. and Davies, L.G. (2014), ―Financial reporting and analysis practices in Small Enterprises: Their association with growth rate and financial performance‖. Journal of Small Business, USA. Vol. 32. No. 1. 23. Ashim Kumar Das and Nikhil Bhusan Dey (2012). Financial Management and Analysis Practices In Small Business: An Exploratory Study in India. National Institute of Technology, Silchar, India., Assam University, Silchar, India. 24. Holmes, Scott and Nicholls, Des (2018). ―An Analysis of the use of accounting information by Australian Small Business.‖ Journal of Small Business Management, USA. April.

Swati Anand*

Department of Rural Management, Babasaheb Bhimrao Ambedkar University, Lucknow, India swatiana@gmail.com