Study the Correlation between Corporate Governance Norms and Growth of the Life Insurance Sector

Examining Financial Reporting Practices and Corporate Governance in the Indian Insurance Sector

by Ashish Bansal*, Dr. Satish Chandra,

- Published in Journal of Advances and Scholarly Researches in Allied Education, E-ISSN: 2230-7540

Volume 16, Issue No. 5, Apr 2019, Pages 1189 - 1194 (0)

Published by: Ignited Minds Journals


ABSTRACT

Insurance sector is a developing segment in India. Section of private and outside insurance companies has made profoundly aggressive and unpredictable condition in the insurance advertise. In such a domain, a straightforward arrangement of financial announcing is important to ensure the interests of policyholders and different partners. Present study, Corporate Reporting Practices of Insurance Sector in India is led to break down the financial announcing practices of life and general insurance companies. The investigation depends on the yearly reports of Indian insurance companies for a time of 8 years for example from 2002-03 to 2009-10. Different records for example compulsory exposure file, intentional divulgence file and record identifying with corporate governance things are built. Unweighted exposure scores are utilized to dissect the financial detailing practices of these companies.

KEYWORD

corporate governance norms, life insurance sector, insurance sector, financial reporting, policyholders, stakeholders, annual reports, compulsory disclosure, voluntary disclosure, unweighted exposure scores

INTRODUCTION

In any financial sector of an economy, the insurance industry contributes towards the financial sector as well as gives a significant government disability net in the creating countries. In India, the development of the insurance sector has been exceptional. In the course of the most recent couple of years, the insurance industry has experienced an enormous change and this change has been meriting consideration. In India there are numerous private and government insurance companies that have gotten synonymous with the term insurance. The insurance companies are offering numerous administrations and making the arrangement of the policyholders' as indicated by their necessities. Along these lines these companies have figured out how to be prominent in the Indian Insurance Industry

History of Insurance in India

Insurance has a profound established history in India. It discovers notice in the works of Manu (Manusmrithi), Yagnavalkya (Dharmasastra) and Kautilya (Arthasastra). It talks as far as pooling of assets that could be re-disseminated in the midst of common cataclysms, for example, fire, floods, plagues and starvation. This resembled an antecedent to the cutting edge insurance. Insurance in India has developed after some time vigorously drawing from different nations, particularly England. In 1818, with the appearance of extra security business in India, the Oriental Life Insurance Company in Calcutta was set up. This Company flopped in 1834. The Madras Equitable had started executing extra security business in the Madras Presidency in 1829. The British Insurance Act appeared in 1870 and over the most recent three many years of the nineteenth century, the Bombay Mutual (1871), Oriental (1874) and Empire of India (1897) appeared in the Bombay Residency. Be that as it may, this time was ruled by remote insurance workplaces which were doing great business in India, specifically Albert Life Assurance, Royal Insurance, Liverpool and London Globe Insurance. These outside companies were giving an exceptionally hard challenge to Indian insurance companies.

Indian Life Insurance in Global Context

"The life coverage industry is a significant player and supporter of the country's financial development. The industry is likewise basic for the feasible development of a country". Insurance is essential to the economy for its monetary and nation. India is the fifth biggest life coverage market on the planet and it is developing at the pace of 32 to 34 percent annually. According to Swiss Re report, the portion of disaster protection industry in absolute premium of the entire world was 55.6 per cent3. Out of this the portion of life coverage business of India was a lot of high at 79 percent and the portion of non-disaster protection business was exactly at 21 percent. In life coverage business, India is positioned tenth among the eighty eight nations. In 2014, India's offer in global extra security market was 2.08 percent and it has expanded to 2.24 percent in 2015. Notwithstanding, during 2015, there was an expansion in the extra security premium in India 7.8 percent while it has expanded by 4 percent for the disaster protection premium of the entire world.4 The insurance sector has become significant on the grounds that the commitment of administration sector in Indian GDP is 55.2 percent as per Union Budget 2010-11 of which 5.4 percent originates from banking and insurance.

Concept of Corporate Financial Reporting

The concept of corporate financial reporting has increased a lot of centrality because of the extension and development of organization type of association, expanded challenge and increment in the data needs of the clients (Singh, 2005) The corporate financial reporting is an arrangement of correspondence between the administration and the client gatherings of the financial articulations; so as to report the aftereffects of the business exercises of a corporate endeavor and furthermore to show the believability, responsibility and unwavering quality of its working Kohler's lexicon for bookkeepers characterizes it as a clarification or display appended to a financial explanation, or typified in a report containing a reality, conclusion or detail required or accommodating in the translation of the announcement or report. According to American Accounting Association the financial reporting is the development of data from the private area (for example inside data) into the open space. It is a procedure through which a substance speaks with the outside world.

Components of the Corporate Governance Guidelines

The IRDAI has secured the accompanying principle basic components of the Corporate Governance in the Insurance Companies:

Governance Structure

The private safety net providers in India are yet not recorded on the stock trades. In the event of the Public Sector Undertakings (LIC), the piece of the recommends every one of the back up plans to have suitable information about the Corporate Governance structures and different necessities of the recorded elements. The authority likewise prompted these companies to begin the proper strides to encourage the simple change at the hour of their posting in any trade.

Board of Directors

According to the Insurance Act, the insurance companies in India would be open companies and in this manner they are required to have an appropriately established Board involving qualified and the able chiefs who are equipped for making techniques in such a way, that would be advantageous for the insurance organization and will likewise secure the interests of the considerable number of partners including the policyholders. The size and sythesis ought to be with the end goal that they can give information, their aptitudes, experience and so forth and they ought to likewise have the option to give adequate time and the pledge to finish their obligations. It is likewise expressed in the rules that the executives ought to be chosen or named by the investors of the companies from various specialized topics like fund, insurance, banking, bookkeeping, financial matters, worldwide markets and so forth., having the suitable capabilities.

OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY

1. To build up how the recurrence of holding gatherings influences a firm‘s budgetary execution. 2. To build up how the quantity of executives a firm has influences a firm‘s budgetary execution.

REVIEW OF LITERATURE

So as to discover the gaps in explore, the literature effectively accessible relating to the issue was audited. The literature on life insurance industry in India incorporates books, summary, postulations, theses, study reports and articles distributed by academicians and specialists in various periodicals. The survey of this literature gives a plan to focus on the unexplored territory and to make the present investigation increasingly unmistakable from different examinations. The accessible literature is isolated into four sections based on the measurements showed up through the audit of various ponders on the point and to comprehend

Studies on Different Corporate Governance Approaches

Thefollowingresearchpapersandthearticlesarepresentingthestudiesondifferentcorporate governance approaches, both at Indian and at the international level. Jairus, Banaji et. al. (2001) has studied the corporate governance issue for the huge private area organizations in India and the changing administrative condition. The examination has indicated that the leading body of the Indian organizations are not compelling, there is absence of straightforwardness in the related party exchanges, there is huge hole in the bookkeeping rehearses in India from the global practices, and the disputable institutional investors. The scientists were of the conclusion that the administrative bodies should made the free executives more grounded and the assignment boards of trustees ought to be made a compulsory panel. It was likewise proposed in this examination that a progressively dynamic methodology ought to be embraced for the corporate governance of the institutional speculators, more changes ought to be presented, for the idea of the money related establishments' possession and the administration control, more opportunity for the institutional administrators and the advancement of the market for better control. Gompers et. al. (2003) has communicated in their investigation that from the perspective of the financial specialist the corporate governance is a guarantee to give a reasonable profit for capital contributed by the speculators. Sinha, Sidharth (2009) has inferred that monetary changes and advancement have changed BSNL and MTNL from state-possessed restraining infrastructures to players in an exceptionally aggressive market with no social targets. These organizations will run like other private area telecom organizations on the off chance that they need to endure and succeed. The current approach of government, where constrained self-sufficiency is given to these organizations based on size, benefit and an ostensible posting, isn't fitting if these organizations need to contend with the private part. Brogi, Marina (2010) in her paper has detailed that in spite of the fact that the arrangement producers and the institutional financial specialists gave incredible significance to corporate governance still blended proof was found on the connection among size and structure of the board and execution. The banks and the insurance organizations were found to have bigger sheets contrasted with different organizations and it was seen that the size of the board doesn't adversely influence execution. time. Prior, it was thought to be implementation of the agreements, assurance of the privileges of the property and aggregate activity. It was accepted that governance is connected with the people working inside any associations. It was deduced in this paper to accomplish the obligation of ensuring the enthusiasm of the policyholder's the insurance firms ought to have the suitable great governance strategies. Chaudhary et al (2011) has examined the status of life insurance industry after certain progressions were presented by the IRDAI in the standards and guidelines in the life insurance part. In the examination it was brought to the notice that the life insurance area has developed at a high rate from 2000 onwards, as far as number of strategies, premium assortment, number of workplaces, number of operators, number of items and so on. Jairus, Banaji et al (2001) has studied the corporate governance issue for the huge private area organizations in India and the changing administrative condition. The examination has indicated that the leading body of the Indian organizations are not compelling, there is absence of straightforwardness in the related party exchanges, there is huge hole in the bookkeeping rehearses in India from the global practices, and the disputable institutional investors.

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

Research Design

A specific technique for an examination is utilized based on the degree, reason and test of the investigation. It additionally relies upon the resources accessible to the analyst (Gill and Johnson, 2002). The distinct research technique is utilized subsequent to thinking about the idea of the exact investigations of the examination. The causal research technique is utilized for looking at causal relationship between various factors. Illustrative look into strategy gives a thought regarding the current status and the qualities of a specific marvel.

Population, Sample and Time Period of The study

As the investigation has considered the degree of consistence with corporate governance best practices by Indian Life Insurance segment, thus all the life insurance companies working in India will be the populace and test with the end goal of the examination. In India there are twenty three life insurance companies in the private area and just The timespan for the examination is from 2005-06 to 2014-15. The data for all the corporate governance factors, growth factors, performance factors and monetary quality factors were taken from 2005-06 to 2014-15 for the examined life insurance companies in India.

Data Collection

The investigation was led by collecting data through primary and secondary data sources. A poll overview was accomplished for the assortment of primary data in connection to check the consistence with corporate governance rehearses. The goal to utilize the survey was to check the bits of knowledge of executives towards the operational part of corporate governance structure. Secondary data in connection to growth, performance, money related quality, corporate social obligation and the corporate governance data were assembled from the yearly reports of the life insurance companies and IRDAI. Different journals, books, monetary papers, magazines, dailies and week by week reports of different foundations and online journals like J Store, Sage publications and so forth were likewise utilized.

Design of the Questionnaire

An organized survey was set up to know the perspectives of the executives of the life insurance companies about the various rules gave by the life insurance companies and whether these companies are clinging to these arrangements or not. The various traits of the corporate governance structure were characterized under six measurements, which structure the premise of the survey. All inquiries were in the shut structure and the vast majority of the inquiries expect a 'yes' or 'no' reaction, as it is the review of adherence with corporate governance best rehearses. Also these kind of inquiries were posed to improve the reaction rate.

DATA ANALYSIS

It is accepted that more is the adherence to corporate administration, there will be improvement in the presentation and the financial quality of the organization. When there is great corporate administration, there will be better basic leadership and no wastage of corporate assets by the administration. The financial specialists additionally wish to make investment in the better represented companies. In this segment an endeavor has been made to discover the effect of the consenting to the corporate administration rehearses on the presentation and financial quality of the extra security companies. This has been tried based on making suspicion that adherence to corporate administration will improve the exhibition and financial quality. The exhibition and financial quality of the disaster protection companies, the example has been isolated into two sub tests, as high consistence companies and low consistence companies based on the CGI scores of the extra security companies.

Impact of Adherence to Corporate Governance on the Performance and Financial Strength of Life Insurance companies

The companies scoring more than the mean score (77.12) of CGI scores of all the disaster protection companies are ordered as the High Compliance Companies and the companies scoring not exactly the mean score (77.12) of CGI scores are arranged as Low Compliance Companies. Thirteen companies have their CGI score more than the mean score. Ten companies have their CGI score not exactly the mean score. So based on this, 13 firms are high consistence companies and 10 firms are low consistence companies. The bookkeeping execution was estimated in the examination with the variable ROA, ROE and PBT/NP. The market execution was estimated by the EPS of the organization. For estimating the financial quality the total assets of the organization was taken. The engaging insights of the CGI Scores and the presentation and financial quality of the existence safety net providers is appeared in Table.

Descriptive Statistics

Through Table 4.9, the expressive insights of CGI score and the factors of execution and financial quality of the disaster protection companies of the absolute example, high consistence and low consistence companies are appeared. In the event of the absolute example, the mean of CGI score is 77.12, standard deviation is 2.91, least CGI score is 69.6 and the most extreme is 82.4. In the event of high consistence companies the mean of CGI score was 79.03, standard deviation was 1.687, least score was 77.4 and the most extreme was 82.4 while if there should be an occurrence of low consistence companies the mean was seen as 74.64, standard deviation was 2.18, least score was 69.6 and most extreme score was 77. It demonstrates that there is an incredible contrast in adherence of corporate administration rehearses over the life coverage companies. The normal ROA if there should arise an occurrence of complete example was seen to be 0.0023, in the event of high consistence organization it was 0.0075 and in the event of low consistence organization, ROA was seen as - 0.0045. There is a huge distinction between the ROA of both high and low consistence companies. It shows that high consistence with the corporate

higher if there should arise an occurrence of high consistence companies when contrasted with the low consistence companies. The mean score of the total assets of the low consistence companies (81,939.16 lakhs) is lower than the mean score of the complete example ( 1,26,084.13 lakhs) just as the high consistence companies ( 1,60,041.80 lakhs). Subsequently, it very well may be said that the exhibition and the financial quality of the disaster protection companies improve as there is more adherence to the corporate administration standards and the practices. Be that as it may, if there should arise an occurrence of ROE, the mean estimation of low consistence companies (0.309) was seen to be more noteworthy than the mean estimation of high consistence companies (0.108).

Table 1 Descriptive Statistics of CGI Score, Firm Performance and Financial Strength Correlations Analysis and t-test Results Correlation Analysis

This investigation has taken the accompanying issues: a.) regardless of whether high consistence companies have preferred financial and market execution over the low consistence companies and b.) the following issue is whether the high consistence organization improves the financial quality of the organization. This was checked by utilizing relationship examination and free example t-test. The logical table 4.10 is depicting that the Karl Pearson's coefficient of connection of CGI was negative with the presentation variable ROE for the absolute example (- 0.482) and it is noteworthy additionally at 5 percent level, High consistence companies have low positive relationship with all the exhibition and financial quality factors though the low consistence companies' CGI scores have negative connection with the ROA (- 0.051) and ROE (- 0.795). The t-trial of centrality for autonomous example was likewise applied to test the high and low consistence companies with the goal to check statistically noteworthy contrast in the presentation and the financial quality of the two sub tests and their corporate administration adherence. The Table 4.11 delineates that the mean distinction of ROE (- 0.200808) was negative, indicating that high corporate administration consistence negatively affects the ROE. The mean contrasts of ROA, EPS and Net Worth are sure yet are not statistically noteworthy at the 5 percent level of importance. The mean distinction of PBT/NP (0.1080648) is sure and it is noteworthy additionally at 5 percent level as the p esteem is 0.010. This shows better corporate administration brings about better market execution and better financial quality of the existence safety net providers. Be that as it may, the bookkeeping execution measure ROE has indicated a negative association with the consistence of corporate administration measures. In this manner, it was set up that the high consistence companies have better execution and financial quality when contrasted with the low consistence companies.

CONCLUSION

In the rising global markets, corporate governance is essential to have increasingly monetary advancement and to decline financial emergency. Be that as it may; in the present situation the research on analyzing the appropriateness of the corporate governance rehearses followed in the creating markets isn't much when contrasted with the investigations made for the created countries. Indian life insurance advertise is likewise a developing market and very little research work has been done on the corporate governance works on being followed in this segment. Consequently, through the present investigation an endeavor has been made to look at genuinely the corporate governance works on being followed in the Life Insurance Sector in India and its impact on the growth, performance and financial quality of the life insurance players working in India. In the present section the summary of the results accomplished in the examination are shown; target insightful discoveries of the investigation are given in a concise way and the ends based on the discoveries are likewise clarified. An endeavor has likewise been made to give a few proposals based on the results of the investigation lastly the extent of further research is given at last.

REFERENCES

1. Abdullah S.N. (2006), ‗Director‘s Remuneration, firm‘s performance and Business in Society, 6 (2) pp. 162-174. 2. Adhikari, A. and Tondkar, R. H. (2013), ‗Environmental Factors Influencing Accounting Disclosure Requirements of Global Stock Exchanges‘, Journal of International Financial Management and Accounting, 4, pp. 75-105. 3. Allan. M., (2010), ‗Six Principles of General Insurance: A Comprehensive Guide to Utmost Good Faith, Indemnity, Subrogation, Contribution, Insurable Interest& Proximate Cause‘, Victoria, Australia, pp. 6-8. 4. Aluchna, Maria (2009), ‗Does good corporate governance matter? Best practice in Poland‘, Management Research News, 32(2), pp. 185-198. 5. Anderson, C. W. and Campbell, T. L. (2003), ‗Corporate Governance of Japanese Banks‘, Journal of Corporate Finance, 189, pp. 1-28. 6. Arora, R., (2002), ‗Financial Reforms and Service Sector–A Study of Life Insurance Industry in India‘. 7. ‗A Pre-launch Survey Report of Insurance Awareness Campaign‘ sponsored by Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority, pp. 1-148. 8. ‗Corporate Governance review of the mid-market listed companies in India‘, A study by Grant Thornton in association with FICCI, Corporate Governance Review 2010-11, pp. 5-35. 9. ‗The Changing Face of Indian Insurance, In Pursuit of Profitable and Sustainable Growth‘ A study by BCG in association of FICCI, January, 2016. 10. Baranoff. E. (2004), Risk management and insurance (pp. 29-30). Danvers: Wiley.USA. 11. Barathi, C., Balaji, D., Ibhal Meitei, C. (2011), ‗Innovative Strategies to Catalyse Growth of Indian Life Insurance Sector- An Analytical Review‘, Indian Journal of Commerce and Management Studies, 1 (5). 12. Basavanthappa, C. and Laxman, Rajanalkar (2009), ‗Performance of Life Insurance Companies: A Comparative Study‘, Southern Economist, pp. 28-42. 14. BawaSumninder Kaur, ChatthaSamiya (2013), ‗Financial Performance of Life Insurers in Indian Insurance Industry‘, Pacific Business Review International, 6(5), pp. 44-52. 15. Benjamin MwanziaMulili and Wong, Peter (2011), ‗Corporate Governance Practices in Developing Countries: The Case for Kenya‘, International Journal of Business Administration, 2(1), pp. 14-25

Corresponding Author Ashish Bansal*

Research Scholar, OPJS University, Churu, Rajasthan

baindasunil123@gmail.com