Study on Management Commitment to Service Quality
A Study on the Impact of Management Commitment on Service Quality in Indian Banks and Insurance Companies
by Mateti Chandra Shekhar*, Dr. N. P. Sharma,
- Published in Journal of Advances and Scholarly Researches in Allied Education, E-ISSN: 2230-7540
Volume 4, Issue No. 7, Jul 2012, Pages 0 - 0 (0)
Published by: Ignited Minds Journals
ABSTRACT
Out of the 800 distributedquestionnaires, we could collect 615 questionnaires. Only 530 of the returnedquestionnaires by whatever methods were found suitable for final analysis andwithout discrepancies. Remaining 85 questionnaires were rejected as they wereincomplete in one respect or the other. The detailed description of the samplecan be seen through Table 3.1. Out of the sample of 530respondents, 312 (150 government sector and 162 private/multinational)respondents were from banks and 218 (123 government sector and 95private/multinational) were from insurance companies. All respondent employees/managers were of Indian origin.
KEYWORD
management commitment, service quality, questionnaires, final analysis, sample
---------------------------♦----------------------------- INTRODUCTION
There is no room for debate over the rising importance of services in today’s world. This has been established well in the previous chapter on review of literature by various researchers over the time. The service sector dominates the economies world over. India is no exception. We as a nation are developing and being active members in the world trade, we need to know the rules of the game. Presently, the Indian service sector is in a developing state. The competition at such stages ought to be intense. To achieve a competitive advantage companies, are striving hard to develop competencies. The capabilities in the form of human resources are a must for every firm focusing on providing quality services to secure a competitive edge. The human resource practices of a firm and employees behaviour may affect the quality of services. Moreover, it is imperative for any organization to provide quality services to secure customer loyalty which is important for the firm performance. The study was aimed at studying the impact of human resources practices on service quality. It also aimed at assessing the impact of employees’ behaviour on service quality in service industry.
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
A research design is the plan, scheme, blueprint, series of procedures, conceptual framework to describe how the defined problem will be catered to. The entire structure and strategy of the use of data to information i.e. from its collection, through its editing, to its analysis is a research design. The present study was exploratory and causal in nature. Exploration was needed for this study as the variables for human resource management practices and service behavior antecedents of employees were large in number. Moreover, these variables have not been standardized and formalized in researches so far. Exploratory research design was used for chapters 4 and 5. After establishing the human resource management and service behaviour variables and factors, we needed to know how these variables will affect service quality performance variable. In causal research design, the concern is: how one variable affects another or is responsible for change in another (Cooper and Schindler, 2008). Thus, a causal research design was used to see the effect/impact of human resource management variables and employees’ service behaviour antecedent variables on service quality performance and further, the effect/impact of service quality performance on intentions to resign and job satisfaction. The relevant data for the present study has been obtained from primary sources. A well-structured and pre-tested questionnaire was used for data collection. The questionnaire was drafted consulting relevant literature (Yavas et al., 2003; Schneider et al., 1980; Peccei and Rosenthal, 2001; Hogan et al., 1984; Schneider and Bowen, 1985). We also interacted with some employees in the service sector before finalizing the questionnaire. Before collecting data from respondents, primary drafts of the questionnaire were pre-tested. Based on the written and verbal
2
were stated negatively to avoid the response bias. The questionnaire consisted of three sections. The first section contained 16 background questions and second section contained 18 statements about the human resource management practices. The third section contained 39 statements related to employees’ service behaviour (Appendix-2). The background questions in the first section were related to gender, marital status, age, work experience of the employee in that organization, the overall work experience of the employee, and the number of organizations changed by the employee. Questions were also related to number of employees in the organization, employee union for the organization, percentage union membership, whether HRM department exists in the organization etc.
MATERIAL AND METHOD
Statements related to human resource management practices were 18 in number including statements on human resource practices like job analysis, human resource planning, recruitment policy, socialization, training and development, performance appraisal, service performance, pay for performance, compensation, benefits, workforce diversity, HR information system, career management, attitude surveys, and adoption of new HR practices. The third section contained 39 statements on service behaviour antecedents of employees focusing on employee rewards, staff training, empowerment, teamwork, role ambiguity, organizational commitment, service quality performance, intentions to resign, job satisfaction, co-worker support, role modeling and leadership style items, internalization of service excellence, job competence, and job autonomy. The scaling technique used was non-comparative, itemized rating scale i.e. Likert scale. The respondents were asked to rate statements on a five point rating scale where one indicated that respondents strongly disagree, two meant for disagree, three for neutral, four indicated agreeing and five meant strongly agree about what was described in the statement. This technique was used owing to its easier construction and administration, as it is easier for respondents to understand its usage. Each questionnaire was accompanied by a covering letter (request letter) and authorization letter from the Haryana School of Business, which stated the purpose of research, encouraged voluntary participation by employees, ensured the anonymity of their responses, and thanked the respondents for their cooperation. The universe comprised of male and female employees of banks and insurance companies in the companies in India was prepared, with the help of newspapers, magazines and internet. For getting permission for survey we wrote letters to the head offices of banks and insurance companies. After not getting favourable response and keeping the time, distance and cost involved in mind, we decided the method of convenience sampling to approach the banks and insurance companies personally and seek permission. A sample was taken from the universe in a manner that would foster both the quality and representativeness of data to facilitating better analysis and interpretation. The commercial banking industry in India is characterized by the coexistence of three distinct ownership groups: public banks, private banks, and foreign banks (Kumbhakar and Sarkar, 2003). Hence, we decided to visit banks that would lie in each of these categories. Finally, we got permission from six banks and four insurance companies. Out of the six banks, two public banks i.e. State Bank of India (SBI) and Punjab National Bank (PNB), two private banks i.e. The Industrial Credit and Investment Corporation of India Limited (ICICI) and Housing Development Finance Corporation Bank Ltd (HDFC Bank Ltd), and two foreign banks i.e. Citi Bank and Standard Chartered Bank, became the part of the study. The Insurance Industry has a number of players too. We personally visited the insurance companies also and got permission from four insurance companies. Out of the four insurance companies twocompanies were from the public sector and two were from private sector. Public companies were Life Insurance Corporation (LIC) and Oriental Insurance Corporation (OIC). Private/multinational companies were TATA-AIG and AVIVA Life insurance. On the basis of the permission for survey we got from the head offices, the questionnaire was administered to 800 respondents of six banks (two governments and four private/multinational) and four insurance companies (two governments and two private/multinational). Eighty questionnaires were decided to be distributed to each organization, which were further divided amongst the branches of that organization randomly depending on the number of employees present at that time of the survey (who were present at the date and time of the survey which was decided for a particular organization). Thus, random sampling was used to administer the questionnaires to the respondents. As soon as we finished distributing 80 questionnaires to a particular organization and its various branches, we stopped the distribution and moved to the next organization. The questionnaires were distributed personally with the permission letter by visiting the institutions and their branches.
Mateti Chandra Shekhar1 Dr. N.P. Sharma2
employees’ service behaviour antecedents through discussion and interview. On the same day, few filled up questionnaires were obtained back. For the rest of the questionnaires two more visits were paid to each branch. Few questionnaires from each branch were also received through mail. Finally, The overall response rate was 66.25%. The brief distribution of the sample is presented in Table 3.2.
Total Number of Insurers in India 3. Type of insurance company and no. of employees