The Impact of Specialised Professional Accountancy Implications on accounting Research: A Future Concern

Examining the Impact of Specialised Professional Accountancy on Accounting Research

by Ms. Monika Bhatia*,

- Published in Journal of Advances and Scholarly Researches in Allied Education, E-ISSN: 2230-7540

Volume 15, Issue No. 5, Jul 2018, Pages 723 - 726 (4)

Published by: Ignited Minds Journals


ABSTRACT

Specialized or Professional accounting are being interpreted as an area of accounting, as defined by the governing professional association of accountants, and is handled by accounting practitioners in that sector.The article addresses the potential impact of accounting curriculum and accounting specialist societies in the discussion on the profile and standard of accounting education research. This study analyses the main financial reporting professional societies in India. The piece makes a substantial background by applying the principle of institutional logic to the literature on professional accounting associations (PAAs) showing the prevailing commercial logic of the educational function and the more conventional fiduciary logic of the Professional function. Investigation has shown that the key players in the vocational financial reporting curriculum development strategy are PAAs and employers, while the accounting profession is conspicuously absent.The relative autonomy of curriculum and research and professional roles throughout PAAs is often established professional research and technological practises have little impact on vocational education and inversely. Moreover, PAA support for academic study is popular in many countries for brand identification and, in some cases, to control legislation instead of instruct professional curriculum materials.These analysis may facilitate stakeholders in assessing the results of specialized accounting in emerging and developed economies and guide potential interventions. The minimal research studies examining the relationship between PAOs and accounting research and offers perspectives from two roundtables facilitated by the International Accounting Education and Research Association. Developers define possibilities for study and concerns for research design. We hope this work will promote the advancement of this literature by accounting researchers.

KEYWORD

specialised professional accountancy implications, accounting research, specialized accounting, accounting curriculum, accounting specialist societies, financial reporting professional societies, institutional logic, professional accounting associations, vocational financial reporting curriculum, PAAs

1. INTRODUCTION

Especially in comparison to other fields of accounting research, research in accounting education has long been known to be less widely respected (Marriott, Stoner, Fogarty, & Sangster, 2014; Sangster, 2015) that has raised fears that this might have a detrimental effect on the results of future accounting higher education (McGuigan, 2015). Consequently, questions have also been reported regarding the consistency of literature conducted in conventional accounting journal articles (e.g., Basu, 2012; Demski, 2007; Hopwood, 2007; Moser, 2012). Potentially affecting mean that research publications stagnates (Moser, 2012), has very little impact on professional practise (Basu, 2012; Demski, 2007; Hopwood, 2007; Kaplan, 2011) and has been strongly influenced by studies on accounting and business (Oler, Oler, &Skousen, 2010).We describe integrated response for the purposes of this study as the generation of financial information, accounting skills training as the transmission of accounting knowledge, and practice as the usage of accounting information. The assumption that there might be a circular interaction in between three is objectively true. The utilisation of information (activity) inevitably contributes, for instance, to the development of knowledge (research); the method of sharing knowledge (education) encourages suppliers and users to establish their own meanings and understandings (research); and the participation of students in clinical practise, such as internships, has become a learning. The publication's contribution is really in four fields. First, the article provides a substantial background to the revolutionary application of the principles of institutional logic to the discourse on PAAs, illustrating the leading economic reasoning of the deeper understanding and the more prevalent fiduciary logic of the Professional function. Institutional theory has recently been extended to

2005). Greatly, in certain cases, such alliances even expanded throughout their conventional territorial limits to create innovative multinational organisations. Second, there is evidence that the main players in the production of the accounting programme are PAAs and employers, where the voices of the academy are largely quiet. The goal of the PAAs is to establish generic qualifications that 'future proof' of the employability of their newly trained members. Thirdly, the identification of the freedom of education and study and of the professional roles through which the research and Professional practises of the PAAs have very little impact on accounting education and vice versa. Study practises within PAAs are mostly targeted at building awareness of the brand rather than the importance and effectiveness of the certification. Exclusion of research from qualifications means that it relies on clinical experience (practitioners) instead of analysis (intellectuals). Each disengagement of research from curriculum is a crucial consideration for the consistency of accounting academic research. Author believe that this is most of the 'accounting for education study uncertainty' dilemma found by Rebele and St. Pierre (2015, p. 128). Fourth, to add to the narrow corpus of PAA research in the post-professional paradigm (Suddaby, Gendron, & Lam, 2009) or the 'deprofessionalization' phase (Lampe, Garcia, &Tassin, 2016,). As a final point, this paper concludes that PAAs have a role to play in fostering the effect and importance of accounting education study by specifically integrating pedagogical analysis, particularly vocational curriculum creation, into their research strategies. Such pedagogical study could involve the creation and collaboration of an institution and a specialized programme. Business school educators have long understood the role of higher education in the development of relevant experience and a successful learning approach. For instance,, this becomes effective to educate whether accounting principles are required and how they've been created, and not just to concentrate on the quality of day-to-day accounting principles.

2. LITERATURE REVIEW

Specialised Accounting inquiries (e.g. architecture, law, medicine) typically refer to a variety of distinguishing features, as methodological analyses of occupations appear to resist a clear description (Carnegie, Edwards, & West, 2003). For example: the body of experience and understanding; the desire to self-regulation and discipline; the nature of a code of ethics, trust-based relationships with the customers, the belief that members behave as professionals; and the ability to obtain improved remuneration as a result of professional credentials (e.g., Carr-Saunders & Wilson, 1933; Goode, 1961; Greenwood, 1957; on a sense of social responsibility above and beyond the compensation and benefits that accrues to professional jobs (Carr-Saunders & Wilson, 1933; Lee, 1995). The growth of the public accounting profession has been the subject of continuing academic attention. The Pathways Research (2012 ) proposed the transformation of accounting into such a learned discipline that combined accounting, schooling, and practise. Richardson's (2017) impressionistic past is regarded to underpin the growth of the accounting profession. Consecutively, six steps are identified: • The growth of the profession; • Closing of the profession; • Engagement with the state and the incorporation of accounting skills into regulation; • Globalization of markets; • Commercialization; • The development of hybrid entities with evolving features. For the purposes of this study, concentrate on the final three phases of the globalisation, commercialization and development of hybrid institutions with evolving features. As a result of globalisation, the accounting professionalization programme is distinguished by a commercialisation process. Richardson (1997, p. 635) claims that, at best, the professionalization of accounting has been partial. This represents the failure of the discipline to secure formal approval for their professional domain, a non-standard basis for the education of their professionals, and a shift in business trends away from the conventional core audit and accounting services. In fact, the accounting industry is said to have become too competitive to allow accounting professionalization to develop (Richardson, 1997). Moreover, the sector itself has switched from self-control to regulation (e.g. Sarbannes-Oxley (SOX) introduced in the US in 2002) after a whirlwind of financial crises at the turn of the 21st century (see Lampe et al., 2016). Accounting companies were keen to establish new business lines away from the conventional areas. These 'Specialized accounting companies' no longer use the title 'Chartered Accountants' in their names, and the main audit service line is now mostly just a small portion of their fee revenue. As a result , companies have switched from the professional model to the commercial model (Hanlon, 1994, 1997).

Greenwood, 2007). As a result of financial scandals and formal regulation of accounting practice, the accounting profession has been characterised as non-directional and has followed a range of tactics, often described as a phase of 'deprofessionalization' (Lampe et al., 2016, p.3). Numerous different scholars say that the discipline is evolving new hybrid types defined by commercial and specialised reasoning (Richardson, 2017).Following these changes, contradictions between both the regional and the international levels persist. Significant accounting activities operate internationally within the context of IASB‘s international accounting principles and international professional federations, such as IFAC, but local PAAs continue to flourish (Ramirez 2009). Interestingly, recent research refers to the role of worldwide accounting practises; a much more slender body of work considers the importance of local PAA models. .

3. OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY

The paper has three targets. • To consider the functions of the specialized education and technical departments. • To explain how specialized education and technical departments communicate with each other and, in turn, with accounting. • Third, to recognise the prevailing structural logic of the technical and educational departments of the PAAs

4. DESCRIPTIVE ANALYSIS

The research objectives were to grasp the roles of PAA's education and technology departments, their participation and interplay with each other and the systemic reasoning behind their actions. Thornton et. al., ( 2012) explored four dimensions of developments in the dynamics of higher education in accounting: mission conflicts, market triggers, trends in governance, and changes in dominant institutional logic. Themes contained in the interview data qualitative analysis were organised into different dimensions. Clinebell (2008) says that undergraduate programmes were initially suspected of being elite colleges and that the academic element of business literacy was reacted. Another big move to provide more real-world preparation is now noticeable because university teachers also find education at the professional level. Paisey and Paisey (2017) build this part into academic qualifications, giving way to an atmosphere that is more corporate and technological. Evidence has shown that PAAs have adopted more strong characteristics in part of their practise, with focus on education, like specialist accounting firms. I assume that professional bodies have a competitive number of ways. This was noticeable that perhaps the PAAs all had a clear commercial emphasis, demonstrated by goals for growing student enrolment that would ultimately become full members, creating a successful PAA annuity. Also there was indication that the professional bodies respected only research that was important or beneficial to the accounting practitioner and discounted the academic side of the analysis. Research & development and curriculum appeared to be detached from their vision, which was compounded by systemic tensions. This described the conflict between analysis, with its underlying fiduciary logic 'advancing accounting science' and the 'applied' commercial essence of education, and its 'dirty oily mechanic' leader's quest for pragmatism. Consequently, in one PAA, research and development has been incorporated into curriculum development as a way of justifying research expenditure. Such that, by connecting research and development to the program, added value has been explained.The development in PAAs was effectively implemented by the major PAAs included in this report. Perhaps, this is compatible with the more prevalent logic of accounting and finance. The problem of disseminating the findings of independent research in a fashion and form that could be used by professionals remains a major challenge for the curriculum. The application of an impact variable to study selectivity exercises is being applied in the India and under consideration in the other parts of world. The potential consequence of this will be to have more visibility and thereby enable professional researchers to generate more applied research and reports that are of more interest to academics. The result of such an impact measure would be a closer alignment with the research styles and forms sponsored by the PAAs and the commercial rationale of the PAAs themselves. The results of the study and some of the policy implications are explored in the final section.

5. CONCLUSION

The article starts also with assertion that contemporary educational research has long been a bad relation, relative to other fields of accounting research. In particular, issues have been raised as to the detrimental effect this could have on the value relevance of financial education future studies. The aim of this paper was to explain the PAA 's relationship with the accounting profession. There was a particular interest in which the PAAs used accounting training research as part of such research and in the significance and function of such research for the PAAs. This research includes

fiduciary axioms like accounting firms that employ or are operating by too many of their members . The study would enable PAAs to provide better support and engage in accounting training research through the use of their research initiatives that allow PAAs to present their analytical reserve existing in their research projects. In specific, our study highlights the importance of task disputes, business causes, policy dynamics and improvements to the prevailing logic suggested by the Commission.It offering grants to early career accounting researchers would therefore demonstrate the importance of such studies to the academy, and this would offer much-needed funding to young academics. It could provide financial support for early career researchers to provide mentorship services piloted in 2018 by the Accounting Education Special Interest Committee of the Accounting and Finance Association and under consideration by the same group of India Accounting and Finance Association. This should be a catalyst for the trustworthy rationale of the business company, rather than funding branding or the financial benefits that are mainly ignored or rejected by the accounting profession, to follow a sincere and dedicated approach to developing a curriculum. If researchers interested in accounting studies are given more support and resources, the accounting profession will benefit from a more proof-based approach to teaching both at university level as well as PAA.

REFERENCES

Basu, S. (2012). How can accounting researchers become more innovative? Accounting Horizons, 26(4), 851e870. Pathways. (2012). The Pathways commission on accounting higher education: Charting a national strategy for the next generation of accountants Bruce K. B. (C.), William F. E., Leslie A. M.urphy, Judy D. R.ayburn, Melvin T. S.tith, Jerry R. S.trawser. Issues in Accounting Education, 27(3), 595e600. Carnegie, G. D., Edwards, J. R., & West, B. P. (2003). Understanding the dynamics of the Australian accounting profession: A prosopographical study of the founding members of the incorporated institute of accountants, victoria, 1886 to 1908. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 16(5), 790e820. Carr-Saunders, A. M., & Wilson, P. A. (1933). The professions. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Corresponding Author Ms. Monika Bhatia*

Assistant Professor, School of Management Studies, Ansal University, Gurugram