Study on the Effect of Austempering Temperature and Time on the Corrosion Resistance of Carbidic Austempered Ductile Iron (CADI) Material

Investigation of corrosion resistance and hardness of carbidic austempered ductile iron

by Sanket P. Mahadik*, Madhavi S. Harne, Vijaykumar B. Raka,

- Published in Journal of Advances in Science and Technology, E-ISSN: 2230-9659

Volume 13, Issue No. 1, Mar 2017, Pages 234 - 240 (7)

Published by: Ignited Minds Journals


ABSTRACT

Carbidic austempered ductile iron (CADI) has emerged as a promising engineering material to replace the ADI for higher wear resistance. It induces interest to study the corrosion behaviour of the material in chloride media, bearing in mind that equipment made from this material may be in constant contact with such media. Corrosion resistance of ductile cast iron is improved by the incorporation of an extra phase in the matrix which typically consisting of some carbides. The objective of the present work is to produce carbides in a ductile cast iron which is subsequently austempered to obtain CADI. Six variants of CADI were produced by heating carbidic ductile iron (CDI) to a austenitization temperature of 975 ºC for the period of 1 hr and quenching it in a salt bath at temperature 325 ºC and at 250 ºC for periods of 1 hr, 2 hr and 3 hr at each temperature. The corrosion resistance was evaluated by using salt spray fog test in accordance with ISO 9227 standards. The mechanical properties- bulk hardness, micro hardness evaluated and microstructure of the CADI were characterized by optical microscope and SEM. CADI sample at Austempering temperature 250 ºC and austempering time 1 hr has given best hardness 58 HRc and lesser corrosion rate 0.2094 mm/year which indicates best corrosion resistance.

KEYWORD

austempering temperature, austempering time, corrosion resistance, carbidic austempered ductile iron, CADI, corrosion behaviour, matrix, carbides, ductile cast iron, salt spray fog test

INTRODUCTION

A new type of ductile iron, containing carbides immersed in the typical matrix of DI called CDI. CDI with typical ausferritic matrix is called CADI. CADI is a ductile cast iron containing carbides, that are induced either thermally or mechanically that is subsequently austempered to produce an ausferritic matrix with an engineered amount of carbides. Since its introduction in the 1970s, the usage of ADI has constantly increased. ADI material has been widely used as a structural material in the machine, automobile and agriculture industries. CADI has relatively low production costs but excellent properties, such as high tensile strength, satisfactory impact toughness and good fatigue resistance under dynamic loading conditions and excellent wear resistance [1]. CADI has attracted intensive attention in many areas such as railway, mining industry, defence structures, gears, pinions, crankshafts, centrifugal pump blades, transmissions, suspensions, earth-moving and construction equipment, etc. [2]. Corrosion rate can be measured by using different corrosion testing methods such as electrochemical test, salt spray test and total immersion test. The choice of the corrosion testing method depends upon many factors such as nature of environment, nature of exposure, type of specimen, etc. Salt spray fog test is one of the corrosion testing methods, which involves the exposure of specimens to fine spray as mist of sodium chloride solution at a specified temperature. The spray particles settle upon the test surface (which is preferably inclined) and constantly replenish and replace the film of solution on the surface [3]. The extent and nature of the corrosion of the metal or coated surface after a specified period of exposure

2

the pH of the media or the concentration of the media can be varied [4]. The purpose of present study was to examine microstructure, assessment of mechanical properties and determining the corrosion resistance of CADI.

EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE

A. Material and Sample Preparation:

The pattern used in the present experiment was made of wood with standard allowances and proper finishing; the standard square casting of 15×15×200 mm was produced in the green sand mould. Six CADI samples obtained by casting were heat treated, involving an austenitizing stage of temperature 975 ºC in a muffle furnace for 1 hr, followed by an austempering in a salt bath at two different temperatures of 325 ºC and 250 ºC for different quenching times of 1 hr, 2 hr and 3 hr. Test bars were cut in two samples of dimensions 15×15×8 mm and 15×15×13 mm to test the sample for microstructural characterization and hardness measurement. As-cast sample and six CADI samples were cut to 30x10x5 mm samples by wire cut EDM. Three sets of each such sample were made for improving the accuracy by averaging the corrosion rate. Salt spray fog test was used for calculating this corrosion rate. Sample identification was done on the basis of heat treatment parameters as given in Table 1 below.

Table 1 Identification of sample according to process parameters Sr. No. Process Parameters Sample ID

1 3) Austempered at 250 °C for 1 hrs. A1 2 Austempered at 250 °C for 2 hrs. B1 3 Austempered at 250 °C for 3 hrs. C1 4 Austempered at 325 °C for 1 hrs. A2 5 Austempered at 325 °C for 2 hrs. B2 6 Austempered at 325 °C for 3 hrs. C2 7 As-Cast-CDI D

The chemical composition of CADI sample was measured by means of a spark emission optic spectrometer as shown in Table 2. Metallographic sample preparation for optical microscopy examination was conducted by using standard grinding and polishing techniques and etching with 2% Nital. After the specimens have been cut to desired shape, they were made plane by grinding on grinding wheel. After grinding was done, samples were taken for polishing by different grade silicon carbide papers - 600, 800, 1000, 1200, 1500 µm. After polishing and grinding, further polishing for getting mirror finish was done by using rotating wheel with nylon cloth mounted on it and Alumina paste for minimum 15 minutes. The images of microstructure obtained from optical microscopy were of 100X, 200X, 300X and 500 X magnifications.

Table 2 Chemical composition of As-cast CDI Alloying element Wt. %

C 2.19 Si 2.21 Mn 0.58 S 0.0048 P 0.0179 Cr 2.09 Cu 0.60 Ni 0.45 Ti 0.013 Mg 0.043

C. Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM):

A scanning electron microscope (SEM) is a type of electron microscope that produces images of sample by scanning it with a focussed beam of electron. The electrons interact with atoms in the sample, producing various signals that contain information about the samples surface topography and composition. SEM Jeol Jsm-6380A was used for scanning of samples at different magnification and photographs were taken.

D. Mechanical Tests:

Rockwell hardness was measured at 150 kg load (HRc) on C-scale. A hardness profile was obtained for each alloy. In order to determine the hardness of the carbides and the matrix separately, microhardness tests were carried out by using a Vickers indenter at a 200 g load (HV200).

E. Salt Spray Fog Test:

Corrosion resistance of samples were investigated by Salt Spray Fog test. The corrosion rate was evaluated by using weight loss method as per ASTM

Sanket P. Mahadik1*, Madhavi S. Harne2, Vijaykumar B. Raka3 2

standards. The specimens were placed in salt spray chamber for the duration of 480 hrs (21 days) as per ISO 9227 and cleaned by using mechanical method as per ISO 8407:1991.

Fig.1.CADI Samples prepared for Salt Spray Fog test.

RESULTS AND DISSCUSSION

A. Micro Structural Characterization:

Microstructure in Fig.2.d shows white portion which are carbide traces along the grain boundary and Fig.2.b shows dark portion that is ausferrite. Microstructure Fig. 2.f shows black circular spots which are the graphite nodules. All the six microstructures show carbide traces, ausferrite and graphite nodules which indicate CADI formation.

Fig.2. (a) A1-250 0C 1 hr- 200X

Fig.2. (b) B1-250 0C 2 hrs- 200X

Fig.2. (c) C1-250 0C 3 hrs- 200X

Fig.2. (d) A2-325 0C 1 hrs- 200X

Fig.2. (e) B2-325 0C 2 hrs- 200X

(c) (e) (d)

Carbide Ausferrite

(a)

2

Fig.2. (f) C2- 325 0C 3 hrs- 200X B. Scanning Electron Microscope:

After austempering CDI samples, the matrix was ausferritic, exhibiting the typical morphology i.e. reinforcement of carbide and ausferrite, which was visible in SEM.

Fig. 3 (a) A1 250 ºC-1 hr- 2500X

SEM of Fig.3.b shows greyer portion which are carbides while grey portion in small pieces is retained austenite and dark needle like structure indicate ausferrite. Fig.3.a shows large amount of carbides as visible grey portion and dark spots which are graphite nodules.

Fig. 3: (b). B1 250ºC-2 hr- 2500X

Fig. 3: (c). C1 250 ºC- 3 hr- 2500X Fig. 3: (d). A2 325 ºC- 1hr- 3000X

Fig. 3: (e). B2 325 ºC-2 hr- 2500X Fig. 3: (f). C2 325 ºC- 3 hr- 2500X

(f) (b) (e) (a) (d)

Nodular Graphite Nodular Graphite Carbide Retained Austenite Retained Austenite

Sanket P. Mahadik1*, Madhavi S. Harne2, Vijaykumar B. Raka3 2

The bulk hardness (HRc) was determined as an average of five measurements. Figure 4 shows that the bulk hardness values of all CADI samples are higher than as-cast. It is clearly seen that at the lower austempering temperature, 250 ºC, finer ferrite and lower amount of high carbon austenite are present, which in turn raise the hardness of the specimen. At higher austempering temperature of 325 ºC, coarser ferrite and also higher amount of high carbon austenites are present, which in turn reduce the hardness of the specimen. Retained austenite increases with decreasing austempering time at low austempering temperature of 250 oC. In other words, austenite with low carbon does not transform to bainitic ferrite and high carbon austenite.

Fig. 4 Comparative graph of Bulk Hardness

Unstable austenite has been transformed to martensite and this martensite gives hardness to the microstructure. Hence the hardness for sample A1 is higher than other samples i.e. 58 HRc. whereas, at high austempering temperature (325 ºC), there is sufficient diffusion of carbon to the austenite to stabilize it, and less martensite may form during cooling to room temperature. Hence the hardness for sample A2 is lower than A1 sample (48 HRc).

D. Micro Hardness of Samples:

The Vickers microhardness was used for determining hardness. The average of five measurements was taken for each sample. Microhardness of carbide phase is found around 700HV200 to 985HV200 and for other than carbide phases, i.e. for ausferrite around 350HV200 to 550HV200. From fig. 5 it is seen that in matrix of CADI microhardness values show random change which is because carbides are randomly precipitated throughout the sample.

Fig. 5 Comparative graph of Micro-Hardness.

E. Corrosion Rate of CADI Samples:

Salt spray fog test is qualitative method for identifying corrosion behaviour of metals and their alloys [9]. Photographs of CADI samples, shown in fig. 6, indicate that holes and pits were present on metal surface which implies that pitting corrosion takes place. Corrosion rate of each sample was evaluated as per ASTM G1-03.

Fig.6 Corroded CADI samples.

Corrosion rate = mm/year [10]. Where, K = Constant =

2

A= Corroded Surface Area, cm2

T=Time of exposure in hrs. . D=Density of CADI material in gm/cm3

Table 3 Corrosion rate of CADI samples. Sr. No CADI Samples Corrosion Rate (mm/year)

1 AS-CAST 0.2646 2 A1(250 ºC -1 hr) 0.2094 3 B1(250 ºC -2 hr) 0.2162 4 C1(250 ºC -3 hr) 0.2543 5 A2(325 ºC -1 hr) 0.2604 6 B2(325 ºC -2 hr) 0.2562 7 C2(325 ºC -3 hr) 0.2381

Table 3 shows the comparisons of corrosion rate of as-cast sample with CADI. Experimental results of CADI samples show same nature as that of as-cast, i.e. corrosion rate of CADI increases with increasing austempering time. Investigation shows that at lower austempering temperature (250 ºC) corrosion rate is less as compared with higher austempering temperature (325 ºC). It can be concluded that retained austenite mostly affects corrosion resistance of CADI material and their formation rate is dependent on austempering temperature and time. Fig. 7 shows that at lower austempering temperature (250 ºC), the rate of nucleation of ferrite is more, but the diffusion rate of carbon into austenite is very low which leads to the formation of fine ferrite and retained austenite. When austempering time increases from 1 to 3 hr, as shown in fig. 7, corrosion rate also increases which is because of retained austenite becoming stable.

Fig.7: Austempering temperature and time effect on corrosion rate of CADI samples.

At 250 ºC temperature and 1 hr time i.e. A1 sample has more corrosion resistance among A1, B1 and C1. At higher austempering temperature (325 ºC), the austenite becomes stable at start and with increase in

CONCLUSIONS

An attempt was made to study the effect of austempering temperature and time on corrosion resistance of CADI material. The major conclusions derived from this experimentation are: 1. It was observed in microstructure and SEM of samples that carbide, ausferrite, retained austenite and graphite nodules were present, so it can be concluded that CADI can be formed. 2. The samples austempered at higher austempering temperature had significantly higher corrosion rate which implies lesser corrosion resistance. 3. It was observed that CADI samples at lower austempering temperature of 250 ºC had more resistance to corrosion as compared with CADI samples at higher austempering temperature of 325 ºC. 4. At higher austempering temperature of 325 ºC, the corrosion resistance increases with increasing austempering time; C2 has highest corrosion resistance among A2, B2 and C2. 5. At lower austempering temperature of 250 ºC, the corrosion resistance decreases with increase in austempering time; A1 has highest corrosion resistance among A1, B1, and C1.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

Authors would like to acknowledge the Department of Metallurgy and Material Engineering, VNIT Nagpur, Maharashtra, India, for providing the facility for heat treatment and characterization of CADI samples. Also, we would like to thank Videocon Private Limited, Aurangabad for providing us facility of salt spray fog test.

REFERENCES

[1] Ch. F. Han, Q. Q. Wang, Y. F. Sun, J. Li, “Effect of Molybdenum on the Wear Resistance and Corrosion Resistance of Carbidic Austempered Ductile Iron” Metallogr. Microstruct.Anal, Vol.4, pp.298-304 (2015). [2] Jinhai Liu, Guolu Li, Xuebo Zhao,Xiaoyan Hao, “Effect of Austempering temperature on Microstructure and properties of carbidic Austempered ductile iron”, Advanced

Sanket P. Mahadik1*, Madhavi S. Harne2, Vijaykumar B. Raka3 2

1088(2011).

[3] A.S.Afolabi, “Effect of Austempering temperature and time on corrosion behaviour of ductile iron in chloride and acidic media”, Anti-corrosion methods and materials, vol.58, pp.190-195(2011). [4] C.H. Hsu, M.L. Chen, “Corrosion behaviour of nickel alloyed and austempered ductile irons in 3.5% sodium chloride” Corros. Sci. vol. 52, pp. 2945–2949 (2010). [5] H. Krawiec, J. Lelito, E. Tyrała, J. Banas´, “Relationships between microstructure and pitting corrosion of ADI in sodium chloride solution.”J. Solid State Electrochem, vol.13 (6), pp.935–942 (2009). [6] S. Laino, J.A.Sikora, R.C.Dommarco, “Development of wear resistant carbidic austempered ductile iron (CADI)”wear.vol.265, pp.1-7(2008). [7] “The Salt Spray test and its use ranking stainless steels” International stainless steel forum.(2008) [8] Yoon-Jun Kim, Hocheol Shin, Hyounsoo Park, “Investigation into mechanical properties of austempered ductile iron in accordance with austempering temperature”, Material letters vol.62, pp.357-360(2008). [9] “Corrosion test in artificial atmospheres-Salt Spray test” ISO 9227, (2006). [10] “Standard Practice for Preparing, cleaning and evaluating corrosion test specimens”, ASTM-G1-03,Annual book of ASTM standard.(2003) [11] Joel Hemanth, “The solidification and Corrosion behaviour of Austempered Chilled ductile Iron” „Journal of material processing Technology, vol.101, pp.159-166(2000). [12] “Standard practice for operating salt spray fog test apparatus”, Transaction of ASTM B117-94, pp.1-8, (1994).

Corresponding Author Sanket P. Mahadik*

Engineering, Chh. Shahu College of Engineering Aurangabad, Maharashtra, India

E-Mail – sanketmahadik104@gmail.com