Development of Low Cost Sugarcane Harvester for Maharashtra Region: A Review

Improving Efficiency and Reducing Costs in Sugarcane Harvesting: A Review of Low Cost Harvesters for Maharashtra Region

by Amit S. Lomate*, P. B. Khope, M. S. Giripunje,

- Published in Journal of Advances in Science and Technology, E-ISSN: 2230-9659

Volume 14, Issue No. 2, Sep 2017, Pages 5 - 9 (5)

Published by: Ignited Minds Journals


ABSTRACT

In today’s world agriculture plays a very important role in India compared to other sectors. Around 4.6 million hectares of land is used for cultivation of sugarcane. India stands second in the growth of sugarcane in the world. Farmers are facing a vast problem labour day by day because people migrating from rural to urban places is causing of labour shortage in the rural areas. Sugarcane is a major crop of India. Sugarcane harvesting has been mechanized using automated harvesting and a new set of mechanisms has been introduced to make the existing machine more efficient, economical and less complicated for serviceability. At present there are good sugarcane harvesters in market. But these sugarcane harvesters are very costlier and generally owned by Sugarcane factories. Today we have surplus sugar production in our country. Sugarcane cultivation and harvesting costs are tremendously increased. In short Industry is facing lot of difficulties. Only way to survive is to adopt creative ways to cut production cost. So there is the need of new sugarcane harvester that can be coupled with Tractor PTO (Power Take Off).

KEYWORD

sugarcane harvester, low cost, Maharashtra Region, labour shortage, mechanization, efficiency, economy, serviceability, sugar production, production cost

1. INTRODUCTION

With this Sugarcane Harvester mechanization attached to tractor Sugarcane industry will have their harvesting costs reduced. Labour associated with harvesting will be reduced without reducing employment. Sugarcane harvesting could also be side business to farmers. Sugarcane Industries no more have to worry about investments associated with harvesting. It will be developed in such a way that it can be attached to any tractor available with farmers. The harvested sugarcane will be dumped in the trailing trolley associated with the tractor. There is also a possibility of using an extra engine apart from that of tractor engine. Harvesting of sugarcane at a proper time i.e., peak maturity, by adopting right technique is necessary to realize maximum weight of the millable canes (thus sugar) produced with least possible field losses under the given growing environment. On the other hand harvesting either under-aged or over-aged cane with improper method of harvesting leads to loss in cane yield, sugar recovery, poor juice quality and problems in milling due to extraneous matter. Therefore, proper harvesting should ensure: ● To harvest the cane at peak maturity (i.e., avoiding cutting of either over-matured or under-matured cane) ● Cutting cane to ground level so that the bottom sugar rich internodes are harvested which add to yield and sugar ● De-topping at appropriate height so that the top immature internodes are eliminated ● Proper cleaning of the cane i.e., removing the extraneous matter such as leaves, trash, roots etc. ● Quick disposal of the harvested cane to factory Several standard analytical methods are available to determine the peak maturity or quality so that the cane is harvested at right time. Without such analysis also several farmers take-up cane harvesting based on crop age and appearance. Sometimes farmers

Amit S. Lomate1* P. B. Khope2 M. S. Giripunje3

2. MANUAL VERSACE MACHINE HARVESTING:

After consultation with number of sugarcane factories in Maharashtra state of India following facts are found: 1. Only 30% of total sugarcane is harvested using sugarcane harvester. Major reason is high initial cost. Other reason includes maintenance and skilled operators. As sugarcane harvesters are functional only for 6 months a year, they remain idle for next 6 months. Because of this idle period these are prone to heavy to moderate maintenance. 2. Manual harvesting has lot of problems. Manpower management is difficult. Fatigue in harvesting workers limit the manual harvesting rate. Operating costs associated with manual sugarcane harvesting are high. 3. Sugarcane harvested from harvesters is to be crushed in limited time. It is because of the fact that sugarcane is cut into number of small pieces using harvesters.

3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

In manufacturing and assembling of different parts of the machine. The machine parts are fabricated after determining the dimensions of the machine parts. The designing job is more like a logical and referred as a highly technical work which involves selection of material properties ascertaining, sizes and dimensions of machine components. But when converts the design into real parts it seems to be very tedious. So manufacturing is considered as a very prominent as well as crucial process which should be carried in a systematic manner and it should be carried out with specified standard. Otherwise machine could fail. Sugarcane industry will have their harvesting costs reduced. Labour associated with harvesting will be reduced without reducing employment. Sugarcane harvesting could also be side business to farmers. Sugarcane Industries no more have to worry about investments associated with harvesting.

For Cutter

Cutting Force required to cut a sugarcane: 150N (This value is found with experiments. Most of the sugarcane harvester literature assume the same value) If diameter of cutter is 300mm. then, Cutting torque = F*D/2 =22.5Nm Now,

P=2*3.14*N*T/60 N=P*60/(2*3.14*22.5) N=0.42*P

When P is in hp, N=0.42*746*P (P is in hp) Tractor has power take off (PTO). PTO delivers rated power at rated rpm. Using this power as I/P sugarcane harvester is actuated. Cutting as well as dumping mechanism is actuated by coupling them with the PTO. This Mechanization can be attached to tractors of power output in the range of 5hp to 25hp. We have tractors available in the market from companies such as: 1. Mahindra 2. Cubota 3. Sonalika 4. John Deers They have variety of tractors depending upon the purpose of their use. Most of the tractors having PTO shaft delivering power in the range of 5hp to 25hp. Some of the models are also capable of delivering power up to 35hp. This mechanization can be fitted on to any of the tractors. Only following things will change. 1. Selection of tractor specific PTO shaft attachment. 2. Selection of driving and driven pulley in case rated power rpm is different.

Amit S. Lomate1* P. B. Khope2 M. S. Giripunje3

Fig. 1 Rear Attachment Assembly Fig. 2 Assembly of sugarcane harvester with tractor

Fig. 3 Manual Harvesting

Fig. 4 Costly Sugarcane Harvesters

5. RESULT AND DISSCUSSION

● Existing machines are complex technologies involving huge costs. Ours is a simple one that can be attached to tractor. ● Operational cost using our machine will be much lower.

Fig. 5 Developed Assembly of sugarcane harvester with tractor

Amit S. Lomate1* P. B. Khope2 M. S. Giripunje3

Manual Harvesting Harvesting with old sugarcane harvester Harvesting with new harvester Fixed cost 0 10000000 250000 Variable Cost per tonnage

550 350 300 0 10000000 250000 2750000 11750000 1750000 5500000 13500000 3250000 8250000 15250000 4750000 11000000 17000000 6250000 13750000 18750000 7750000 16500000 20500000 9250000 19250000 22250000 10750000 22000000 24000000 12250000 24750000 25750000 13750000 27500000 27500000 15250000 30250000 29250000 16750000 33000000 31000000 18250000 35750000 32750000 19750000 38500000 34500000 21250000 41250000 36250000 22750000 44000000 38000000 24250000 46750000 39750000 25750000 49500000 41500000 27250000 52250000 43250000 28750000

Fig. 6 Change of sugarcane harvesting costs along with conditions

A sugarcane mechanical gathering system is also manual and Machine gathering systems. Within the Manual gathering systems, the mechanisms of the sugarcane harvester perform a collection of functions in sequence to finish gathering operation. Full mechanization systems of sugarcane gathering might either be self-propelled whole-stalk harvesters or the chopper harvesters. Machine gathering technology diagrammatical within the tractor mounted and tiny cane harvesters perform one or a lot of the functions done by the total mechanization harvester. Variable styles of tractor mounted further as little sugarcane cutters are developed for the conditions of developing countries. Several styles of sugarcane mechanical harvesters are regionally incontestable for farmers’ acceptance. Most of the incontestable harvesters cut the bases of cane stalks and leave them lying on the bottom. The farmer should decide the cane stalks, top it, clean dry leaves and prepare it during a pile appropriate for loading. Therefore, the farmers verify that the employment of cane cutters don't save price or effort. The makes an attempt of developing a neighborhood cane harvester restricted to graduate students analysis with no probability for field demonstration. It looks like all the countries manufacturing sugarcane have developed undefeated cane harvester for his or her native conditions.

REFERENCES:

Mr. Rohit Masute (2015). “Design and Fabrication of Small Sugarcane Harvester” IJRDO Journal of Mechanical And Civil Engineering: ISSN: 2456-1479 Volume-1, Issue-3, March, 2015 Adarsh J. Jain, Shashank Karne, Srinivas Ratod, Vinay N. Thotadand Kiran P. (2013). “Design And Fabrication of Small Scale Sugarcane Harvesting Machine”, IJMERR ISSN-2278-0149,Vol-2,No-3 July2013 T. Moontree, S. Rittidech and B. Bubphachot (2012). “Development of Sugarcane Harvester Using Small Engine In Northeast Thailand”, International Journal Of Physical Sciences Vol-7(44), pp. 5510-5917, November2012 Yuichi Kobayashi, Kanji Otsuka, Ken Tariwaki, Mitsuho Sugimoto and Kyo Kobayashi (2003). “Development of Kenaf Harvesting Technology Using A Modified Sugarcane Harvester”, JARQ 37(1), pp. 65-69. Yanmei Meng, Yuanling Chen, Shanping Li, Chaolin Chen, Kai Xu, Fanglan Ma, Xiaobio Dai

Amit S. Lomate1* P. B. Khope2 M. S. Giripunje3

of Numeric Simulation of Macromolecule Cleaning Element for Sugarcane Harvester”, August 2008 E. S. Bosoi, O. V. Verniaev, T. I. Smimov, E. G. Sultan-Shakh (1987). Theory, Construction And Calculations Of Agricultural Machines, pp. 175-191.

Corresponding Author Amit S. Lomate*

M. Tech Student, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, PCOE, Nagpur

E-Mail – amitwings@gmail.com